Best Pizza in Buffalo, NY (2026)

Find and order from the top-rated pizzerias in Buffalo. Local reviews, delivery options, and exclusive deals.

🍕 Find Pizza Near Me Now📍 View Local Pizzerias

Pizza Delivery & Takeout in Buffalo, New York

Looking for pizza in Buffalo, NY? You're in the right place. Buffalo is a vibrant mid-size city with a growing pizza scene. Local favorites and regional chains deliver quality pies across the area. Located in the Northeast region, the local pizza culture here is shaped by New York thin-crust and Neapolitan traditions. Whether you're craving a quick delivery, a dine-in experience, or the best pickup deal in Buffalo, PizzaNearMeNow scans real-time data to connect you with the highest-rated pizza restaurants within minutes of your exact location.

🍕 Top Pizza Restaurants in Buffalo

#RestaurantRating
1JJs Casa Di Pizza11 E Mohawk St, Buffalo, NY 14203, USA⭐ 4.2
2Just Pizza & Wing Co.300 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, USA⭐ 3.8
3Pizza Town859 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14213, USA⭐ 4.1
4Extra Extra Pizza549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213, USA⭐ 4.7
5Carbone's Pizza & Subs568 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204, USA⭐ 4.0
6La Nova371 W Ferry St, Buffalo, NY 14213, USA⭐ 4.2
7Imperial Pizza - Main Street1665 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14209, USA⭐ 4.1
8Mister Pizza Elmwood1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, USA⭐ 3.9
9Little Caesars Pizza2290 Delaware Ave STE 200, Buffalo, NY 14216, USA⭐ 3.8
10Franco's Pizza1153 Kenmore Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217, USA⭐ 4.2

Data refreshed hourly via Google Places. Last updated for Buffalo, NY.

📊 Buffalo Pizza Scene at a Glance

Avg. Slice Price$3.00 – $4.50
Price Level$$–$$$
Typical Delivery Radius5–8 miles
Est. Pizzerias Nearby15–50
Peak Order Hours11:00 AM–1:00 PM & 5:30–8:30 PM
Avg. Delivery Time25–45 minutes
GPS Coordinates42.8900°N, 78.8800°W
Regional Pizza IdentityNew York thin-crust

🛒 How to Order Pizza in Buffalo

1

Open PizzaNearMeNow in Buffalo

Visit pizzanearmenow.com and tap "Use My Location" or type your Buffalo, NY address. Our tool uses GPS to pinpoint your exact position.

2

Browse Nearby Pizza Restaurants

See every pizza restaurant near you ranked by distance with live Google ratings. In Buffalo, expect to find 15–50 options within 5–8 miles.

3

Compare Ratings & Reviews

Check star ratings and review counts pulled live from Google. In the Northeast region, local favorites often outperform chains — Skip the chains — the Northeast has the densest concentration of independent pizzerias in the country. Walk-in slice shops almost always beat delivery for quality.

4

Choose Your Order Method

Order via DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub, or call the restaurant directly. Calling direct saves 15–30% on fees. Average delivery time in Buffalo: 25–45 minutes.

🏠 Make Pizza at Home?

Buffalo residents love crafting homemade pies too. Check out top-rated pizza ovens, peels, and dough kits on Amazon.

🔥 Pizza Ovens🍕 Pizza Making Kits🪨 Pizza Stones

As an Amazon Associate, PizzaNearMeNow.com earns from qualifying purchases.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza in Buffalo

What is the best pizza near me in Buffalo, NY?

▼
The best pizza in Buffalo depends on your taste preferences. Use PizzaNearMeNow to find the highest-rated pizzerias near your exact location in Buffalo. We show live Google ratings, review counts, distance, and whether each restaurant is currently open — so you can make the best choice in seconds.

Which pizza delivery apps work in Buffalo?

▼
Buffalo is served by major delivery platforms including DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub. Very strong — walk-up slice shops on nearly every block in major metros. Delivery apps and direct-call ordering are both standard. PizzaNearMeNow shows you all available ordering options for each restaurant, including direct phone ordering which typically saves 15–30% on service fees.

How much does pizza cost in Buffalo?

▼
In the Northeast region, average slice prices range from $3.00 – $4.50. Full pies typically range from $12–$28 depending on size, toppings, and whether you're ordering from an independent pizzeria or a chain.

What pizza styles are popular in Buffalo?

▼
Buffalo is in the Northeast pizza region, where the dominant styles include New York thin-crust, Neapolitan, Coal-fired, New Haven apizza, Bar pie. Local specialties you might find include Pepperoni & fresh mozzarella, White clam pie, Grandma slice.

Can I find late-night pizza delivery in Buffalo?

▼
Late-night pizza availability in Buffalo depends on the day and neighborhood. Most pizzerias in Buffalo close by 10–11 PM on weeknights, with extended hours on Friday and Saturday. Use PizzaNearMeNow to see which restaurants are currently open near you.

Is there gluten-free or vegan pizza in Buffalo?

▼
Options are growing! Check with individual pizzerias in Buffalo for gluten-free and vegan menu items. Use PizzaNearMeNow to find and call restaurants directly to confirm dietary options.

🗺️ Pizza Culture in Buffalo & the Northeast

The Northeast is the historic heartland of American pizza. From the legendary coal-fired ovens of New Haven to the iconic foldable New York slice, this region treats pizza as a way of life, not just a meal.

When ordering pizza in Buffalo, you'll encounter styles including New York thin-crust, Neapolitan, Coal-fired, New Haven apizza, Bar pie. The most popular local specialties are Pepperoni & fresh mozzarella, White clam pie, Grandma slice, Vodka sauce pie, Sicilian square.

Pro tip from the Northeast: Skip the chains — the Northeast has the densest concentration of independent pizzerias in the country. Walk-in slice shops almost always beat delivery for quality.

📍 Find Pizza in Nearby Cities

🍕 Pizza in Rochester

New York · Pop. 100K–500K

🍕 Pizza in Syracuse

New York · Pop. 100K–500K

🍕 Pizza in Cleveland

Ohio · Pop. 500K+

🍕 Pizza in Pittsburgh

Pennsylvania · Pop. 500K+

🍕 Pizza in Detroit

Michigan · Pop. 500K+

← View all cities in New York

Explore Pizza in Other States

AlabamaAlaskaArizonaArkansasCaliforniaColoradoConnecticutDelawareFloridaGeorgiaHawaiiIdahoAll 50 States →